What if I told you that the money in your pocket isn't real? It's just an illusion, a mere promise of value that can vanish overnight. So, what truly counts as real money? In today's world of credit cards, online payments, and cryptocurrencies, the question "What is real money?" might seem more philosophical than practical.
However, understanding the history of money from its inception to the dominance of fiat currency reveals one constant truth: gold has always been real money, unlike fiat currency, which relies solely on trust and can lose value due to inflation or excessive printing.
As J.P. Morgan famously stated, "Gold is money. Everything else is credit." This article explores how money and banking evolved, why gold became the foundation of economies, and why it remains relevant even today.
1. The Origin of Money
From Barter to a Universal Medium
In ancient times, trade was based on the barter system, where goods and services were exchanged directly. While practical in small communities, this system had significant limitations. A farmer who needed shoes might not find a cobbler who wanted grain. The lack of a common medium of exchange made trade inefficient and cumbersome.
To solve these problems, societies began using commodities like salt, cattle, and shells as money. These items had intrinsic value but were often inconvenient to store or transport.
Money is just a medium of exchange. A medium of exchange has certain properties to be called Money. Can we pick up some sand or shells on the beach and call it money anymore?
Properties of Money
The ideal properties of anything to be considered as money include durability, divisibility, portability, uniformity, scarcity, and acceptability.
- Durability ensures that the medium can withstand wear and tear over time.
- Divisibility allows it to be broken into smaller units for varied transaction sizes.
- Portability makes it easy to carry and use in trade.
- Uniformity ensures that each unit is the same as another, facilitating trust and consistency.
- Scarcity provides intrinsic value by limiting supply and preventing devaluation.
- Lastly, acceptability ensures that the medium is widely recognized and trusted for transactions.
These properties form the foundation of what qualifies as real money. Over time, gold emerged as the preferred medium of exchange because of its unique properties:
- Durability: Gold doesn't corrode or decay, ensuring it lasts indefinitely.
- Divisibility: It can be melted and divided into smaller units without loss of value.
- Portability: Gold is dense, so small quantities hold significant value.
- Universally Recognized: Gold's beauty and rarity made it desirable across cultures.
By adopting gold as a medium of exchange, societies created a standard that simplified trade and laid the groundwork for more complex economies. This transition not only facilitated easier transactions but also enabled the growth of civilizations by supporting the development of trade networks, stable markets, and financial systems that could sustain larger and more sophisticated societies.
2. The Birth of Banking
Early Banking Systems
The earliest form of banking can be traced back to ancient Mesopotamia, where temples served as secure storage for grain and gold. These institutions issued clay tablets as receipts, representing a claim to the deposited goods. This practice introduced the idea of money as a claim on stored value.
In medieval Europe, goldsmiths began offering similar services. They stored gold for individuals and issued paper receipts, which could be redeemed for the deposited gold.
The paper receipts were just a promise to pay the value mentioned on it backed by the deposited Gold which is the real money.
Over time, people began trading these receipts instead of the gold itself, as they were more convenient to carry. These receipts were the first form of paper money.
Fractional Reserve Banking
Goldsmiths noticed that not everyone redeemed their receipts simultaneously. Imagine a coat-check system at a theater: not all attendees claim their coats at the same time. Similarly, goldsmiths realized they could issue more receipts than the gold they physically held, confident that not everyone would demand their gold simultaneously.
This practice, known as fractional reserve banking, allowed for increased lending but introduced risks like bank runs if too many depositors requested their gold at once. This insight led to the practice of fractional reserve banking, where banks issued more receipts than the gold they held.
In effect, they created money by lending out gold claims that didn't physically exist in their vaults. While this system increased liquidity and economic activity, it also introduced the risk of bank runs when too many depositors demanded their gold at once.
3. What is Real Money?
The Definition of Money
Money serves three essential functions:
- Medium of Exchange: It facilitates transactions.
- Store of Value: It retains purchasing power over time.
- Unit of Account: It provides a standard measure of value.
Gold uniquely fulfills these criteria. Unlike other currencies such as paper money or digital money, gold's value doesn't rely on trust in a government or institution. Its scarcity and intrinsic worth ensure that it retains value regardless of economic conditions.
The Concept of Credit and Fiat Currency
Credit is money that relies on trust. For instance, a dollar bill is valuable only because people trust the issuing government. This system works as long as trust remains intact, but it's vulnerable to inflation, devaluation, and economic instability.
Fiat currency is government-issued money that has no intrinsic value and is not backed by gold. Its widespread adoption gained momentum during the 20th century, particularly after the United States abandoned the gold standard in 1971.
This shift allowed governments to print money freely, relying on trust and economic policies to maintain value, rather than a tangible asset like gold. Its value is derived solely from the trust and confidence people have in the issuing government.
Unlike gold, fiat currencies are susceptible to inflation and can lose their purchasing power over time. When fiat currencies diminish in value due to excessive printing or economic instability, gold's intrinsic value endures as a trusted store of wealth.
Understanding Value & Inflation
Real money, like gold, retains its value over time because it is tied to intrinsic properties such as scarcity and durability. In contrast, nominal money - such as fiat currency, represents only the face value printed on it, which can lose purchasing power due to inflation.
For example, during hyperinflation in Zimbabwe, the nominal value of their currency soared into trillions, but its real value became negligible. Gold's stability and resistance to inflation make it the foundation of real wealth, unlike fiat money which is susceptible to devaluation through excessive printing. Understanding this distinction is crucial for both personal financial security and broader economic stability.
4. "Gold is Money. Everything Else is Credit"
Understanding J.P. Morgan's Quote
J.P. Morgan's famous statement encapsulates a profound truth about financial systems. Gold is the only form of money that isn't dependent on a promise. Every other form of currency, whether fiat or digital, represents a value claim rather than value itself.
Gold as a Hedge Against Inflation
Throughout history, gold has served as a safeguard against inflation. When governments print excessive money, the purchasing power of fiat currency diminishes. In contrast, gold's value remains stable. For example:
Post-World War I Germany: The Weimar Republic's hyperinflation rendered the German mark worthless, but gold retained its purchasing power.
Modern Examples: During the 2008 financial crisis, gold prices surged as investors sought a safe haven.
The Gold Standard Shift
Gold Standard refers to a monetary system where the value of a country's currency is directly linked to a fixed amount of gold. Under this system, governments and central banks agreed to exchange currency for gold at a fixed rate, ensuring that money was backed by a tangible asset.
This standard provided stability and limited the ability of governments to print excessive amounts of money, as each unit of currency had to correspond to the gold reserves held.
For much of history, national currencies were backed by physical gold. However, the system also restricted economic flexibility, leading many nations to abandon it during periods of financial strain, such as during the Great Depression and World War 2.
The Bretton Woods Agreement of 1944 established the U.S. dollar as the world's reserve currency, convertible to gold at a fixed rate. However 1971, President Nixon ended the dollar's convertibility to gold, ushering in the fiat money era.
This shift to fiat currency allowed governments to print money without restraint, leading to inflation and cycles of economic instability. Without the discipline of the gold standard, currencies became purely credit-based.
Though Banks could create more money by lending, they can't simply do so because it leads to severe economic consequences. Excessive money in circulation would be similar to the sand or shells on a beach, available abundantly but losing its property of scarcity.
Excessive money printing causes inflation, where the value of money decreases, and prices of goods and services rise substantially. Over time, this can erode public trust in the currency and destabilize the economy.
Furthermore, devalued money affects international trade, as other countries may lose confidence in the overprinted currency. Although banks can create money, they must balance this with maintaining economic stability and the currency's purchasing power.
5. Why Gold is Still Relevant Today
Gold's Enduring Value
Despite the rise of fiat currencies and digital payment systems, central banks worldwide continue to hold significant gold reserves. This reliance on gold stems from its role as a hedge against economic crises and inflation. During times of financial instability, gold's value remains stable, providing a safeguard for economies.
For example, in the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis, central banks increased their gold holdings to bolster confidence and stabilize their reserves. This enduring trust in gold underscores its importance as real money. This persistent dependence on gold highlights its function as a value reserve and protection against economic instability.
Gold vs. Bitcoin
In recent years, Bitcoin has been touted as "digital gold." While it shares some properties with gold, such as scarcity and decentralization, Bitcoin lacks gold's centuries-long track record. Moreover, gold's physicality makes it less vulnerable to technological risks, such as cyberattacks or regulatory crackdowns.
Additionally, Gold has wider acceptability as compared to the Bitcoins. This is mostly due to the reason the Gold can be kept at home in a locker or even in banks. But Bitcoins require Crypto wallets which can be accessed and facilitated only through devices connected to the Internet.
The Importance of Real Money
Understanding the difference between money and credit is crucial for financial literacy. Gold represents stability and value that transcends human institutions. In a world of economic uncertainty, holding gold can protect individuals and economies alike.
Does that mean that we should acquire more real money?
Before we answer that question, it is important to know about the economic concepts of Inflation and Deflation.
Inflation erodes the value of nominal money - the money in its current amount because, as prices rise, each unit of nominal money buys fewer goods and services. However, real money, which refers to wealth or assets adjusted for inflation, generally appreciates or retains its value during inflationary periods, especially if invested in real assets like real estate, gold, or stocks.
In an inflationary environment, holding more real money (such as appreciating assets) is preferable, as it helps protect against the loss of buying or purchasing power.
In contrast, deflation raises the value of nominal money since the overall price level of goods and services decreases, allowing each unit of nominal money to purchase more. However, real money can lose value if it is held in cash or non-appreciating forms, as lower demand and prices may stagnate economic growth, reducing the overall value of investments.
During deflation, holding cash (nominal money) may be advantageous in the short term, but long-term wealth building often requires investing in assets that can perform well even in a deflationary environment.
The decision between acquiring more real money (wealth or assets adjusted for inflation) versus nominal money (the current value of money without inflation adjustments) also depends on the individual's financial goals, risk tolerance, and time horizon.
Real Money or Gold (Wealth/Assets)
This is money that holds its value over time, adjusted for inflation. Real money typically includes investments in assets such as real estate, stocks, or commodities like gold, which in the long term tend to appreciate or at least retain their value. Acquiring more real money is generally a better strategy for long-term wealth building because it protects against inflation and can generate passive income or growth over time.
Nominal Money (Cash)
This is the money in its current value, which can lose purchasing power due to inflation. Holding large amounts of nominal money can be risky over the long run as inflation erodes its value. However, it may be necessary for short-term liquidity needs, as cash provides immediate access to spending, emergencies, and opportunities.
Key Considerations
- Inflation Protection: Real assets tend to outperform cash in the long term because they appreciate or hold value, whereas nominal cash loses value with inflation.
- Liquidity: Cash (nominal money) is necessary for short-term expenses, emergencies, or opportunities. However, holding too much cash without investing it can limit growth potential.
- Risk: Acquiring more real money in the form of assets can involve risks (market volatility, asset bubbles, etc.), whereas cash is low-risk but offers lower returns.
The balance between both types may be ideal for enough real assets to build wealth and beat inflation, with sufficient nominal money for short-term needs.
Conclusion
Gold's role as real money is rooted in its intrinsic properties and historical significance. Unlike fiat currencies, which are credit-based, gold's value doesn't depend on trust or promises. As J.P. Morgan said, "Gold is money. Everything else is credit." This timeless truth underscores the importance of understanding money's evolution and recognizing gold's enduring relevance.
In a world where fiat currencies are increasingly disconnected from tangible value, gold remains a cornerstone of financial stability. Whether you're an individual investor or a policymaker, acknowledging gold's unique role is essential for navigating the complexities of modern finance. After all, real money doesn't just facilitate transactions - it preserves wealth for generations.
Gold's story is a reminder that, even in a world dominated by digital transactions and fiat currencies, the value we assign to money is rooted in trust and perception. Though the gold standard is a relic of the past, gold itself endures as a timeless measure of stability, resilience, and universal worth. Its role as a safeguard against uncertainty and its enduring allure as "real money" invite us to question the fragility of modern financial systems.
By learning from the past, we can make informed decisions about the future of money. As the financial landscape evolves, gold's legacy reminds us of the enduring principles that underpin true economic value.
If the foundation of our economies is built on trust, what happens when that trust wavers? Will we lean further into gold’s timeless security, or will new technologies like cryptocurrencies redefine the concept of value? As we move deeper into the complexities of a digital financial future, gold reminds us of a simple truth: the things we value most are often the things we can hold in our hands.
.jpg "Linking to Bookmark in Word Document Saved on SharePoint")
